Wishful Recycling Threatens Single-stream Process | WGLT

Wishful Recycling Threatens Single-stream Process

Jun 26, 2017

Workers sort recycling and contaminants from a conveyor belt at Midwest Fiber
Credit Midwest Fiber

Contamination in the recycling stream at Midwest Fiber threatens the business model that makes single stream recycling possible.  A company representative says if  the contamination rate increases above the current 10 percent, it could cost taxpayers more. 

However, increased education efforts, including a new smart phone app may help curb contamination.

Todd Shumaker, Director of Sales and Procurement at Midwest Fiber, said Bloomington and Normal have a revenue sharing agreement with the company. The value of the recycled materials is calculated, sorting cost are subtracted and any rebate left is paid back to the city and town. 

"If it (contamination) were to increase, then there would have to be discussion about renegotiation," said Shumaker, during Sound Ideas

Contamination, such as a swimming pool liner,  can also lead to costly shutdowns of the sorting facility, according to Shumaker.

"It does happen, unfortunately," said Shumaker. "We've had other pieces of non-conforming materials come through the facility and they get wedged or stuck into holes or wrapped up around sprockets, and shut down the facility." 

Bales of plastic, or PET, ready to be shipped from Midwest Fiber.
Credit Midwest Fiber

Shumaker said some people think there's someone at Midwest Fiber who will pick out items that are hard to recycle and send it where it needs to go. He said that's not true. Much of the process at Midwest Fiber is automated and contaminants, 400 tons per month, go to the landfill.  Shumaker, and  Michael Brown, Executive Director of the Ecology Action Center (EAC) agree there's a component of wishful recycling. The EAC, among other things, works to coordinate the county's solid waste.

"I do like to lean toward the wishful recycling because we get those inquiries on a daily basis," said Brown. "we get people who call us desperately seeking an answer how to recycle this, that or the other and so often it's a consumer good that is not recyclable." 

Both Shumaker and Brown agree that education is the key to keeping the contamination rate low. The EAC has been educating the community about recycling for more than 40 years and will soon put education about better recycling better on individual smart phones. 

"Something we're about to roll out is a new smart phone and web-based application called Recycle Coach which is going to provide people geographic based real time answers to their recycling questions," said Brown, who added the app will also provide information about how deal with specific products. 

Products like single-use, plastic grocery bags. 

"Plastic film, in general, is the number one contamination we see at our facility," said Shumaker. "Plastic bags are by far the biggest percentage of our contamination. They're not always by weight, but by volume.  

He said plastic film wraps around equipment and causes staff to take time to clear the film. 

Brown said the best option for now is to return the plastic bag to the store. Many accept returned bags. Or, he said, aim for "source reduction" by choosing a reusable bag.  

While single-stream recycling increases participation, both Brown and Shumaker agree increased contamination was an expected side effect. Four-hundred tons of contaminants collected at Midwest Fiber are landfilled every month at a cost of $100 per ton. 

WGLT depends on financial support from users to bring you stories and interviews like this one. As someone who values experienced, knowledgeable, and award-winning journalists covering meaningful stories in central Illinois, please consider making a contribution.