Fatal Attraction: How A Young Couple's Dark Journey Led To Murder | WGLT

Fatal Attraction: How A Young Couple's Dark Journey Led To Murder

Apr 8, 2018

When Cullen Hedrick and Brittney Mikesell arrived at a south Bloomington trailer park on a Saturday afternoon in early December, they were looking for trouble.

Hedrick—his face covered with a bandana—carried a machete. Mikesell, his girlfriend, was armed with pepper spray. Police say they were there to fight someone.

Instead, they mistook another man, Rodney Daugherty, for their target, police reports show. Hedrick swung his machete. Mikesell used her pepper spray. Daugherty pulled a knife to defend himself.

“Yeah, I killed him. He stepped out of the shadows, and it happened,” Daugherty told GLT. “The big question I have is, why? That’s what I don’t get.”

Cullen Hedrick, who was killed in the incident Dec. 2, 2017.
Credit McLean County Sheriff's Department

As Mikesell raced a mortally wounded Hedrick to the hospital, she allegedly tossed the machete out of the window. (It’s later found by a pedestrian walking along Hamilton Road.) Motorists saw blood dripping from their Chevy Equinox at a stoplight. Hedrick died in the ER at age 21, and a thrashing Mikesell was charged with mob action and spitting on an EMT during her police interview.

Mikesell, 23, wasn't told Hedrick was dead until two days later. A month later, she was charged with his murder.

The complicated, dangerous relationship between Hedrick and Mikesell is now at the center of that murder case, which was filed under a controversial state law that allows a person to be accused of murder even if they didn’t physically cause the death. More than a dozen interviews and a review of court and medical records by The Pantagraph and GLT reveal two people fighting their own mental illnesses, difficult childhoods, and substance abuse issues.

“They’re not Wilma and Fred Flintstone. They’re Bonnie and Clyde,” said John Day of Downs, Mikesell’s stepfather. “Them two maybe should not have been together.”

RELATED STORY: Mikesell Charged Using Controversial Murder Law

The fatal trip to the Cardinal Ridge trailer park on Dec. 2, 2017, was years in the making for Mikesell and Hedrick.  

As a girl, Mikesell played basketball and volleyball. She went to church camp every year.

The downward spiral in her behavior began around the time she went to high school, which she never finished. She threatened suicide in her early teens and was hospitalized for the first of many times, said her mother, Melody Justus of Downs.

Brittney Mikesell began showing signs of mental illness after the family moved to the Tri-Valley school district around her 15th birthday, her mother said.
Credit Melody Justus / Courtesy

Mikesell was eventually diagnosed with borderline personality disorder and bipolar disorder, Justus said. Around age 20, she resisted arrest and served 40 days in jail after failing her probation.

“You are a product of your environment. She was just in a bad environment,” said Day, Justus’ ex-husband.

By 2016, Mikesell was dating Hedrick—himself a troubled young person.

Hedrick’s childhood was marked with violence, according to records from the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) obtained by The Pantagraph and GLT. He witnessed domestic violence as a child and allegedly pulled a knife on his mother and threatened to kill her, DCFS records show.

Hedrick was diagnosed with schizophrenia, according to the records. His behavior turned darker, more aggressive, around age 12, his mother told police after his death. He spent his 18th birthday at a juvenile detention center, she said.

The combination of mental illness and other challenges faced by Hedrick and Mikesell made their future a risky proposition, according to child welfare staff who compiled the DCFS reports.

“There appears to be a significant risk for future violence in … their relationship,” DCFS staff wrote.

Mikesell secured an order of protection against her boyfriend in October 2016. Months later, she was pregnant. Hedrick was arrested and jailed three times during her pregnancy, records show.

The McLean County jail is accustomed to frequent fliers like Hedrick—those with mental health issues who return again and again. A quarter of all inmates self-report some history of mental health treatment and receive subsequent assistance, said Jacqueline Mathias, inmate specialist and counselor.

Melody Justus of Downs, Brittney's mother.
Credit Ryan Denham / WGLT

“We get everything. You can get everything from general anxiety, or some minor depression, all the way up to active psychosis, active delusions. People hearing voices, people seeing things. Telling you an entire story they believe that you know isn’t possible,” Mathias said. “We see everything that comes in.”

Justus, Mikesell’s mother, said it was hard to keep her in treatment long enough to make a difference. Mikesell twice ended her substance abuse treatment at Chestnut Health Systems and was inconsistent in keeping appointments for mental health services at the McLean County Center for Human Services, court records showed.

“It seemed like nothing that we tried was doing anything for her,” said Day, her stepfather. “It was like she didn’t want no help.”

While Hedrick was in jail in mid-2017, Mikesell’s life seemed to stabilized. She had a gender-reveal party for the baby and was getting excited to be a mother, family said. But then Hedrick was released from jail June 7, 2017.

“Maybe what drew them together is the fact that they both similar problems,” said Day, the stepfather. “That was probably the worst thing for them (being together).”

Their baby girl was born July 4, 2017. The next day a nurse overheard an agitated Hedrick reference the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting and his ability to get a gun despite having a mental illness, DCFS records show. Hospital officials were concerned about Hedrick’s behavior that was recorded in DCFS records.

The state put the baby into protective custody after medical staff reported signs of alcohol and marijuana in the baby’s system, DCFS records show.

The placement of the baby with Mikesell’s aunt further splintered an already divided family. For the next five months, the parents are granted supervised visitation with their child.

Hedrick was arrested again Sept. 12 on a warrant. During booking he struck a guard at the jail and served 46 days in jail and was released Nov. 26, 2017—the week he was killed.

“They were doing numerous things over that time span,” said Kathleen Miller, Mikesell’s aunt who has custody of the baby. “It was one pressuring the other.”

Miller said her willingness to adopt the baby was based on concerns she had that Mikesell and Hedrick would be able to care for the child.

Two days after Hedrick’s final release from jail, Mikesell allegedly pepper-sprayed a woman near a Normal trailer park. Police reports show they were also suspected of beating a man with a baseball bat at a separate trailer park in Normal. Family told police they suspected the couple was dealing drugs.

The couple stayed up until 4 a.m. the night before Hedrick’s death, talking about their relationship and her withdrawal issues from spice—a mind-altering synthetic drug. Mikesell was “freaking out like a demon” that night, and that Hedrick was reading the Bible to her, she later told police.

LOOKING FOR SOMEONE

Authorities have not publicly disclosed why they think the couple went to 23rd Street in the Cardinal Ridge trailer park—with their mask, machete, and pepper spray—in broad daylight on a Saturday afternoon.

Brittney Mikesell and Cullen Hedrick arrived at a home in Cardinal Ridge trailer park on Dec. 2, 2017, where Hedrick was stabbed to death in a confrontation with a stranger.
Credit David Proeber / The Pantagraph

Police reports obtained by The Pantagraph and GLT from Mikesell’s custody case reveal the couple was looking for an acquaintance who briefly lived with Mikesell while Hedrick was jailed.

“Mikesell stated the whole point of this incident was to find (that person) and fight him for the disrespect he showed toward her and Cullen,” according to a detective’s narrative of his interview with Mikesell.

Hours before Hedrick’s death, they confronted that person in Heyworth but he got away, police reports show. They chased him back to Bloomington on U.S. 51, arriving at the trailer park. But instead of confronting their target, they came across Daugherty instead, police reports show. It’s a fatal mistake.

In the hours after Hedrick’s death, police tried to sort out conflicting statements about what happened on 23rd Street. Daugherty—his face still burning from the pepper spray—told police the couple attacked him without provocation after he pulled up to a trailer to see a buddy. Daugherty said it was self-defense and that he didn’t know the couple who attacked him. Police believed him and allowed him to go.

Brittney Mikesell after she was arrested in December 2017.
Credit McLean County Sheriff's Department

Mikesell told police Daugherty tried to run over Hedrick. But police reports show Mikesell was an unreliable narrator—distraught, suicidal, and still potentially under the effects of spice, which is found in her bra.

Neighbors told reporters they suspect drugs played a role in bringing Hedrick and Mikesell to the trailer park. Police found drug paraphernalia and spice in their vehicle, court records show.  

“It makes you realize anything can happen in the blink of an eye,” said Samantha Zogg, a Cardinal Ridge resident who got a ride from Hedrick and Mikesell, who Zogg didn’t know, the day before his death. 

TOO CLOSE TO HOME

Neighbors in Cardinal Ridge are used to seeing the police. One neighbor who asked to not to be identified said her family had just returned from a Christmas parade when her kids spotted first responders down the block where Hedrick was stabbed. She knew Cullen and Cullen’s mother.

“He was a lost soul looking for love,” the woman said.

Now the woman says she wants to move out of Cardinal Ridge. “What has happened to Cullen was one of the worst things that’s ever happened out here,” she said. “It’s a little too close to home.”

Sandy Zogg talks with McLean County State’s Attorney Jason Chambers outside the Law and Justice Center in Bloomington recently as she called for lengthy prison sentences for perpetrators of extremely violent crimes. Zogg lives in Cardinal Ridge where Brittney Mikesell, 23, is alleged to have been involved in the death of Cullen Hedrick on Dec. 2, 2017.
Credit David Proeber / The Pantagraph

Zogg’s mother, Sandy Zogg, lives one street over from where it happened. She plans to leave too.

“I don’t like the things that go on out here. It’s not a good place to be,” Sandy Zogg said. “It’s sad for the people who’ve been here for years. It’s sad what it’s turned into.”

For now, Mikesell is being held at the McLean County jail on $2 million bond, meaning she must post $200,035 to be released. Two weeks ago, she agreed to terminate her custody rights to her 8-month-old daughter.

Hedrick is buried at Pleasant Grove cemetery in Downs. His family declined repeated requests for an interview for this story. An aunt said only that his "family loved him so much."

“Our family is struggling with the sudden loss of Cullen, and words cannot describe the pain that we are dealing with at this time,” his mother wrote on a crowdfunding website to help raise money for his funeral. “No parent should ever have to bury their child.”

Coming Monday: A closer look at the custody case involving Brittney Mikesell, Cullen Hedrick, and their baby, born just months before their fatal encounter at the trailer park.

People like you value experienced, knowledgeable and award-winning journalism that covers meaningful stories in Bloomington-Normal. To support more stories and interviews like this one, please consider making a contribution.